2004 All-AMC South Division Team
(Selected by vote of the division coaches)
Player of the Year - Ben Hunter, Rio Grande
Coach of
the Year - Eric Nichols, Ohio Dominican
Freshman of the Year - Wayne Maden,
Rio Grande
Fair Play Team Award - Cedarville
| FIRST TEAM | Name | Yr | School | Hometown | ||||
| Goalkeeper | Andrew Moore | Fr | Rio Grande | Manchester, England | ||||
| Defender | Mark Fahey | Sr | Rio Grande | Preston, England | ||||
| Tim Thomson | Fr | Cedarville | Monroeville, PA | |||||
| Aaron Moses | Jr | Ohio Dominican | New Lebanon, OH | |||||
| Midfield | Ben Callon | Jr | Rio Grande | Blackburn, England | ||||
| Michael McManus | Sr | Rio Grande | Belfast, Northern Ireland | |||||
| Eamonn Dooley | Jr | Tiffin | Luton, England | |||||
| Forward | Ben Hunter | So | Rio Grande | Doncaster, England | ||||
| Simon Carey | Sr | Rio Grande | Preston, England | |||||
| Ronald Mugabi | Sr | Tiffin | Jinja, Uganda | |||||
| Chris Trefzger | Sr | Ohio Dominican | Grove City, OH | |||||
| SECOND TEAM | Name | Yr | School | Hometown | ||||
| Goalkeeper | Eric Pfiefer | So | Ohio Dominican | Westerville, OH | ||||
| Defender | Jamie Hilen | Sr | Mount Vernon Nazarene | West Chester, OH | ||||
| Justin Kempton | Sr | Tiffin | Strongsville, OH | |||||
| Steve Rose | Sr | Walsh | Marietta, OH | |||||
| Midfield | Sam Hayes | Fr | Walsh | Blackburn, England | ||||
| Phil Ellis | Jr | Cedarville | Cincinnati, OH | |||||
| Zack Weaver | Sr | Urbana | Dover, OH | |||||
| Forward | Josh Baskin | So | Urbana | Englewood, OH | ||||
| Josh Van Pelt | So | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Maryville, TN | |||||
| Leon O'Neill | So | Walsh | Blackburg, England | |||||
| Alex Ferrandez | So | Malone | Elche, Spain |
HONORABLE MENTION: Dave Adams (Cedarville), Cameron Boyd (Tiffin), James Brians (Tiffin), Eric Brockmeier (Walsh), Bryce Burkhardt (Ohio Dominican), Kevin Fischer (Malone), Adam Green (Urbana), Matt Green (Cedarville), Jeffery Hinds (Mount Vernon Nazarene), Ryan Inama (Walsh), Josh Keeney (Shawnee State), Jordan Knight (Mount Vernon Nazarene), Phil Knorr (Ohio Dominican), Ian Lacks (Ohio Dominican), Jake Mahaffey (Urbana), Luc McKinney (Walsh), Gonzalo Perez-Beck (Shawnee State), Kurt Rininger (Shawnee State), Tyler Schumacher (Cedarville), Pat Thompson (Urbana), Nate Watson (Malone), Matt Wilging (Mount Vernon Nazarene), Karinou Yanguere (Tiffin).