2000 All-AMC Team
(Selected by vote of the AMC coaches)
Player of the Year -- Josh Robson, Mount Vernon Nazarene College
Coach of the Year -- David Mor, Ohio Dominican College
| FIRST TEAM | Name | Yr | School | Hometown | ||||
| Goalkeeper | Oliver Sanders | Fr | Rio Grande | Colchester, England | ||||
| Defender | Gerard Tarpey | So | Walsh | Manchester, England | ||||
| Henry Beetoe | Jr | Tiffin | Waterford, MI | |||||
| Sion Chamberlain | Sr | Rio Grande | Llangefni, Wales | |||||
| Midfield | Craig Kench | Sr | Walsh | Leighton Buzzard, England | ||||
| Ron Dezalovsky | Fr | Ohio Dominican | Tel Aviv, Israel | |||||
| Jairo Alvarez | Sr | Ohio Dominican | San Jose, Costa Rica | |||||
| Forward | Josh Robson | Sr | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Mansfield, OH | ||||
| Ali Lukungu | So | Tiffin | Kampala, Uganda | |||||
| Doco Wesseh | Fr | Malone | Monrovia, Liberia | |||||
| Tom Whittaker | So | Rio Grande | Euxton, England | |||||
| SECOND TEAM | Name | Yr | School | Hometown | ||||
| Goalkeeper | Tim Baumgartner | Sr | Ohio Dominican | Cincinnati, OH | ||||
| Defender | Tim Lord | Sr | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Mansfield, OH | ||||
| Marquis Walker | Jr | Malone | Warren, OH | |||||
| Stephen Palmer | So | Cedarville | Massillon, OH | |||||
| Midfield | Michael Swarbrick | So | Rio Grande | Preston, England | ||||
| Rick Collins | Sr | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Pataskala, OH | |||||
| David Schofield | Fr | Rio Grande | Preston, England | |||||
| Forward | Bryan Gratton | Sr | Geneva | Irwin, PA | ||||
| Ronald Arteaga | Fr | Ohio Dominican | Caracas, Venezuela | |||||
| Preston Elifritz | Jr | Mount Vernon Nazarene | Fletcher, OH | |||||
| Mustapha Abbaz | Fr | Ohio Dominican | Morocco |
HONORABLE MENTION: Dave Anthony (Cedarville), Bryan Baugher (Walsh), Chris Chase (Tiffin), Aaron Cook (Cedarville), Brian Davis (Shawnee State), Kurt Gibbins (Walsh), Nick Giovanni (Malone), Ben Goulet (Ohio Dominican), Brad Harger (Malone), Tyler Kirkpatrick (Walsh), Trevor Knowles (Mount Vernon Nazarene), Bryan Macuga (Saint Vincent), Dan Melendrez (Urbana), Vince Nicolosi (Tiffin), Carl Nolan (Rio Grande), Nick Page (Urbana), Rob Piekarczyk (Tiffin), Jeremy Reed (Shawnee State), Josh Stidd (Walsh), Todd Van Culin (Tiffin), Jon Waldo (Cedarville), Roddy Willis (Cedarville).