First Team

# - NAIA Player of the Year
* - Repeat first-team selection from 2003
^ - Repeat first-team selection from 2002

 Second Team

Honorable Mention:
1B -  Casey Funk, Sterling College (Kan.); Carl Galloway, Biola University (Calif.); Ray Gill, Brevard College (N.C.); Kevin Henry, Avila University (Mo.); Kyle Mathieu, Husson College (Maine); Kyle Moore, Ohio Dominican University; Brandon Morris, Lewis-Clark State College (Idaho); Archie Panfilli, Houston Baptist University (Texas); Gary Ray, Purdue University-North Central (Ind.); Dave Rivera, Freed-Hardeman University (Tenn.); Eddie Salgado, Northwood University (Fla.).; Danny Schultz, Jamestown College (N.D.); David Travis, Southern Wesleyan University (S.C.).

2B – Mark Capone, University of British Columbia; Scott Creel, Southern Polytechnic State University (Ga.); Zach DeFrain, Spring Arbor College (Mich.); Al Estrada, Avila University (Mo.); Greg Gabbani, Dickinson State University (N.D.); Glenn Hedgpeth, Azusa Pacific University (Calif.); Victor Joaquin, Fisher College (N.Y.); Dan Matheny, Mount Vernon Nazarene University (Ohio); Brian McGuire, University of Sioux Falls (S.D.); TK Morgan, Claflin College (S.C.).; Patrick Spangler, Lee University (Tenn.); Jason Uhl, Indiana University-Southeast.

3B – Dustin Abel, Bacone College (Okla.); Landon Cortenbach, Concordia University  (Calif.); Josh Ferguson, Husson College (Maine); Steven King, North Georgia College & State University; Jesse Robertson, William Jewell College (Mo.); Arnaldo Rodriguez, Ohio Dominican University; Ryan Runnels, Newman University (Kan.); Greg Stalling, Albertson College (Idaho); Josh Talbott, Lyon College (Ark.); Corey Turchan, Spalding University (Ky.); Anthony Valera, Mount Mercy College (Iowa); Brent Wandler, Mayville State University (N.D.);

SS – Chris Burnsed, Tennessee Wesleyan University; Howard Cuervo, Florida Memorial College; Tyler Driskill, Berry College (Ga.); Joe Engler, Minot State University (N.D.); Josh Forbus, Auburn University Montgomery (Ala.); Chris Grynaviski, Newman University (Kan.); Javier Jimenez, Bethel College (Ind.); Denver Kitch, Oklahoma City University; Robbie Lindsey, Azusa Pacific University (Calif.); Angel Lopez, Ohio Dominican University; Ken Olisky, Fisher College (N.Y.); Jose Rodriguez, Lewis-Clark State College (Idaho); Mark Stalter, Olivet Nazarene University (Ill.).

IF – Ben Blanton, William Jewell College (Mo.); Matt Bocian, Aquinas College (Mich.); Ryan Bruns, College of  St. .Scholastica (Minn.); Brendan Christy, St. Xavier University (Ill.); Calen Laos, Wayland Baptist University (Texas); Mark Listenberger, Dana College (Neb.); Jeremy Lively, Auburn University Montgomery (Ala.); Nate Mayben, Western Baptist College (Ore.); Nick Merrill, Lyndon State College (Vt.); Joe Pichler, St. Vincent College (Pa.); Dustin Price, Milligan College (Tenn.); Ornan Reinoso, Lambuth University (Tenn.); Jud Richards, Point Loma Nazarene University (Calif.); Reggie Rodriguez, St. Thomas University (Fla.).

C – David Bates, William Jewell College (Iowa); Tyler Best, Lewis-Clark State College (Idaho); Kacy Bruce, Campbellsville KY; Travis Casey, Lyndon State; Israel Castillo, Wayland Baptist University (Texas); Darryl Davis, Claflin SC; Jason Folsom, Husson; Adam Hackstedt, Concordia University (Ore.); Mike Hermann, St. Vincent College (Pa.); Travis Hodsdon, Dickinson State University (N.D.); Ryan Kottke, Spalding; Andy Kroeker, Biola University (Calif.); Jesse Kurtenbach, Mount Marty College (Iowa); Ryan Novak, Robert Morris College (Ill.); Travis Nowell, William Carey; Matt Retherford, Bethel TN; Kevin Ritsche, College of St. Scholastica (Minn.); Tony Sanguinetti, Oklahoma City University; Dave Scott, Marian College (Ind.); Ed Senez, Faulkner; Greg Slee, Huntington College (Ind.); Jerrod Spears, William Woods University (Mo.); Jimmy Stanfield, Lee; Stephen Vogt, Azusa Pacific University (Calif.).

OF – Jerry Aldrete, Bacone College (Okla.); Greg Alexander, William Carey College (Miss.); David Allison, Missouri Baptist University; Anthony Bass,Jr., Sterling College (Kan.); Grover Benton, Webber International University (Fla.); Aaron Brideau, Husson College (Maine); Jamie Burgess, Bethel College (Tenn.); Matt Burgess, Auburn University Montgomery (Ala.); Adam Campbell, University of British Columbia; Aaron Coiteux, Concordia University (Ore.); Chris Cole, Thomas University (Ga.); Brad Coon, Trevecca Nazarene University (Tenn.); Roman Cox, Cumberland College (Ky.); Brandon Dale, Oklahoma Baptist University; Pat Gaffny, Fisher College (N.Y.); Cory Gearhart, Point Park University (Pa.); Javier Guevara, Bethel College (Ind.); Kevin Haney, Embry-Riddle University (Fla.); Michael Heyward, Voorhees College (S.C.); Cody Hunter, Friends University (Kan.); Jason Irish, Mount Vernon Nazarene University (Ohio); Sam Joseph, Jamestown College (N.D.); Brent Krause, Jamestown College (N.D.); Matt LeMaster, Indiana Institute of Technology; Jeremy Marion, Fisher College (N.Y.); Ben Martin, St. Ambrose University (Iowa); Robert Neagli, Houston Baptist University (Texas); Todd Niece, Malone College (Ohio); Jader Perez, Mount Mercy College (Iowa); Scott Peterman, University of Rio Grande (Ohio); Preston Picard, Madonna University (Mich.); Brian Porter, Huntington College (Ind.); Kris Price, Faulkner University (Ala.); Cameron Radonich, Azusa Pacific University (Calif.); Jarrett Reardon, Hannibal-LaGrange College (Mo.); Preston Roberts, Brevard College (N.C.); David Seara, St. Thomas University (Fla.); Mike Serrata, Missouri Valley College; Justin Siefken, St. Ambrose University (Iowa); Tom Simonson, College of St. Scholastica (Minn.); Justin Spencer, Husson College (Maine); Darren Terveen, University of Sioux Falls (S.D.); Josh Wettlaufer, College of St. Scholastica (Minn.); Ryan Wilson, Oregon Institute of Technology; Bryce Woods, Newman University (Kan.); Heath Woods, Grand View College (Iowa); Marcus Wyatt, Cal Baptist University; Adam Yoder, Vanguard University (Calif.).

P – Kyle Allen, Lewis-Clark State College (Idaho); Brad Ashman, University of British Columbia; Garrett Bauer, Missouri Baptist University; Brandon Bell, Fisher College (N.Y.); Kevin Brogan, St. Vincent College (Pa.); Scott Brunasso, Concordia University (Calif.); Pete Byrum, Indiana Institute of Technology; Tom Compian, Spring Arbor College (Mich.); Mike Cowperthwaite, Husson College (Maine); Joey Cress, Brevard College (N.C.); Brad Davis, Spalding University (Ky.); Omar Del Canal, St. Thomas University (Fla.); Todd Dunlap, Trevecca Nazarene University (Tenn.); Jake Eiler, College of St. Scholastica (Minn.); Edgar Galindo, William Penn University (Iowa); Greg Gerbasi, Northwood University (Fla.); Jarlin Gomez, Fisher College (N.Y.); Nick Gor, Cal Baptist University; Mike Gurney, Thomas University (Ga.); Reid Hamblet, Biola University (Calif.); Jeremy Helms, Bethany College (Kan.); Doug Holbert, Faulkner University (Ala.); J.J. Jackson, Cumberland College (Ky.); B.J. Jenkins, Trevecca Nazarene University (Tenn.); Kyle Keeton, William Carey College (Miss.); Tom Klapp, Valley City State University (N.D.); John Langan, Bellevue University (Neb.); Chris Langlois, Embry-Riddle University (Fla.); Lance Marcum, McKendree College (Ill.); Joe Martinson, Point Park College (Pa.); Justin Masterson, Bethel College (Ind.); Billy Miskell, Houston Baptist University (Texas); Matt Norfleet, Tennessee Wesleyan University; Tyler Piatz, William Penn University (Iowa); Nathan Poole, Spalding University (Ky.); Travis Ring, Sterling College (Kan.); Adam Rowe, Mount Venron Nazarene University (Ohio); Jonathan Sanchez, Ohio Dominican University; Grant Schara, College of St. Scholastica (Minn.); Josh Shaw, Jamestown College (N.D.); Chuck Smith, Berry University (Ga.); Jeff Steele, Oklahoma Baptist University; Brad Stephenson, Embry-Riddle University (Fla.); Robert Stockton, Dakota Wesleyan University (S.D.); Jose Tadeo, Culver-Stockton College (Mo.); Travis Tripp, Husson College (Maine); Joe Williams, St. Xavier University (Ill.).

DH – Eric Adkins, William Carey College (Miss.); Greg Alden, Flagler College (Fla.); Kyle Anderson, Jamestown College (N.D.); Brian Ayers, Friends University (Kan.); Mike Dunton, Fisher College (N.Y.); Oscar Enriquez, Cal Baptist University; Brett Fuller, Grand View College (Iowa); Jason Pickett, Houston Baptist University (Texas); Jim Queern, McKendree College (Ill.); H.A. Scott, University of Rio Grande (Ohio); Kellen Stevens, Oregon Institute of Technology.

RP – Brian Dunton, Fisher College (N.Y.); Luke Faxon, Bellevue University (Neb.); Luke Franzenburg, Grand View College (Iowa); Adam Gearhart, Indiana Wesleyan University; Justin Hennington, William Carey College (Miss.); Justin Marabeas, Point Loma Nazarene University (Calif.); Nick Seely, Lewis-Clark State College (Idaho); Trevor Stancil, Avila University (Mo.); Tim Sutton, University of Rio Grande (Ohio); Tom Underhill, Brevard College (N.C.); Justin Voigt, Wayland Baptist University (Texas); Adam Walton, Jamestown College (N.D.).