Buehler, a forward from Tallmadge, Ohio, recorded 13 goals and four assists in 14 matches as a senior at Tallmadge High School. She finished with 44 goals and 15 assists for her career and she became the first player in program history to be named to the Suburban League First Team all four years. She was a two-time All-District Second Team selection and a four-time Tallmadge High School Offensive Most Valuable Player. Buehler, who served as a captain during her senior year, also was a Suburban League Scholar-Athlete Award recipient as well as being selected as the Cleveland Plain Dealer Player of the Week once.

"From day one, we knew we really wanted Sarah to be a Lady Cougar,” said MVNU head coach Jonathan Meade. "She has set high standards for herself and has not disappointed in her accomplishments. She is a high character person who has been very successful in the classroom and on the soccer field.”

"As a player, Sarah has proven that she can score goals, and I expect that she will continue doing so at the college level,” added Meade. "In addition, she will bring a physical presence to our attack and continue to add more overall speed to the team. I think Sarah will do very well at the next level.”

In addition to playing soccer, Buehler was a member of the varsity track team as a freshman and earned Suburban League Honorable Mention in the 4x400 relay. She has been involved in Leaders in Action, Student Senate, Pep Club, Letter Winners Club, yearbook staff, and served as a D.A.R.E. role model as well as a Relay for Life team member. She was also selected as the Winter Formal Queen.

"There are several reasons why I chose to attend MVNU,” said Buehler. "I wanted to pursue a nursing career at an excellent academic university, grow in my faith, and continue my passion for soccer. I am excited to have a chance to be a part of a team that is dedicated to personal excellence.”

MVNU posted a 15-7-1 overall record in 2007 and was ranked No. 25 in the final NAIA national poll. The Lady Cougars also claimed a share of their fourth American Mideast Conference South Division title in the past five years, and MVNU has won two National Christian College Athletic Association national titles (2003 and 2006).